We Visited The THALASSA Agia Napa Municipal Museum: A Dive into Cyprus's Maritime Past

The THALASSA (Sea in Greek) Agia Napa Municipal Museum, situated in the heart of Agia Napa, Cyprus, is a treasure trove of maritime history and natural heritage. Established in 2005, the museum's mission is to highlight the integral role of the sea in Cypriot culture and history through a diverse array of exhibits.

Popular Exhibits

One of the museum's most renowned exhibits is the life-size replica of the "Ship of Kyrenia," an ancient Greek merchant ship that sank around 302 BC. This reconstruction offers a detailed glimpse into ancient seafaring and trade. Visitors can marvel at the ship's cargo, which includes amphorae, almonds, and other goods that shed light on ancient commerce.

In addition to the "Ship of Kyrenia," the museum features a rich collection of artifacts spanning from prehistoric times to the modern era. These include fossils, shells, and marine specimens that provide insight into the natural history of the Mediterranean Sea. The museum also showcases various archaeological finds from the region, such as pottery, tools, and jewelry, illustrating the daily lives and craftsmanship of ancient Cypriots.

Educational and Interactive Displays

The museum is designed to be both educational and engaging, with interactive displays that cater to visitors of all ages. The exhibits are complemented by multimedia presentations and detailed descriptions, offering a comprehensive understanding of the maritime and cultural history of Cyprus. The museum's layout is thoughtfully organized, guiding visitors through the chronological and thematic progression of exhibits, making it easy to absorb the rich history on display.

Special Programs and Events

THALASSA Agia Napa Municipal Museum also hosts a variety of special programs and events throughout the year. These include educational workshops, lectures, and temporary exhibitions that explore different aspects of marine archaeology and history. The museum's collaboration with academic institutions and cultural organizations ensures that it remains a dynamic center for learning and discovery.

Conclusion

The THALASSA Agia Napa Municipal Museum is more than just a repository of artifacts; it is a vibrant educational institution dedicated to preserving and promoting the maritime heritage of Cyprus. Whether you are a history enthusiast, a student, or simply a curious traveler, the museum offers a captivating experience that connects the past with the present through the lens of the sea. A visit to this museum is a must for anyone looking to deepen their understanding of the profound influence of the Mediterranean on Cypriot culture and history.

For more information, visit THALASSA Agia Napa Municipal Museum.

View fullsize

View fullsize

View fullsize

View fullsize

View fullsize

View fullsize

View fullsize

View fullsize

View fullsize

Early Astronomy Knowledge of Minoan Crete: The Kastelli Complex and Palaikastro's Matrix

---

By Dimosthenis Vasiloudis

---

The newly discovered Minoan Monumental Circular Architectural Complex at Kastelli and the ancient device from Palaikastro, both from Crete, exhibit remarkable similarities in their circular designs and intricate construction.

The recent unearthing of the Monumental Circular Architectural Complex at Kastelli marks a groundbreaking moment in Minoan archaeology. This complex, defined by a series of concentric stone rings surrounding a central circular structure, showcases the advanced geometric and architectural capabilities of the Minoans. The precision and alignment of these rings hint at possible ceremonial or astronomical uses, suggesting that the Minoans possessed a sophisticated understanding of spatial dynamics and celestial phenomena.

Intriguingly, this architectural marvel bears a striking resemblance to another extraordinary Minoan artifact: the Palaikastro device. This device, predating the Antikythera Mechanism by 1400 years, is regarded as the first analog computer in history. Designed to track celestial bodies, the Palaikastro device underscores the Minoans' capacity for creating complex mechanical tools. The circular design elements of both the Kastelli complex and the Palaikastro device highlight a continuity of technological innovation and intellectual achievement in ancient Crete.

The Kastelli complex's labyrinthine design, featuring radial walls and intricate concentric rings, mirrors the mechanical precision found in the Palaikastro device. This parallelism suggests a shared cultural and technological milieu that fostered advanced scientific and architectural endeavors. The Minoans' ability to integrate practical engineering with ritualistic and astronomical functions reveals a civilization deeply engaged with both the physical and metaphysical realms.

The Kastelli discovery, when viewed alongside the Palaikastro device, illuminates the Minoans' sophisticated approach to both architecture and technology. These artifacts collectively underscore the Minoans' reputation as pioneers of early scientific thought and innovation. As excavations and research continue, we can expect to uncover even more insights into the intellectual and cultural achievements of this remarkable civilization.

---

Debunking The Peace Myth Of The Minoans: New Archaeological Insights Into Warfare And Defense In Bronze Age Crete

---

Further studies on these sites may reveal additional connections between Minoan architecture and early computational devices, offering a more comprehensive understanding of their contributions to the development of science and technology. The intricate designs and precise engineering of the Kastelli complex and the Palaikastro device stand as testaments to the Minoans' advanced knowledge and their lasting impact on the history of human innovation.

10 Modern Cities Influenced by Ancient Hippodamian Urban Planning

---

By Dimosthenis Vasiloudis

---

Modern Cities Influenced by Ancient Hippodamian Urban Planning

The Hippodamian Plan, also known as the grid plan or gridiron plan, is one of the earliest known urban planning systems. It is named after Hippodamus of Miletus, a 5th-century BCE Greek architect and urban planner, often referred to as the "father of European urban planning." Hippodamus introduced this system in the city of Miletus, following its destruction by the Persians in 494 BCE. His approach was revolutionary for its time, emphasizing the importance of order, rationality, and symmetry in urban design. The Hippodamian Plan consists of a layout of streets intersecting at right angles, forming a grid of uniform rectangular or square plots. This methodology not only facilitated navigation and land division but also enhanced civic administration and urban development.

Today, many modern cities around the world have incorporated the principles of the Hippodamian Plan, adapting it to their unique contexts and needs. Here are some notable examples:

1. New York City, USA

New York City, particularly Manhattan, is one of the most iconic examples of a grid-planned urban design, shaped significantly by the Commissioners' Plan of 1811. This plan introduced a systematic grid of streets and avenues that intersect at right angles, creating rectangular blocks and facilitating efficient land use, navigation, and infrastructure development. The grid system allowed for predictable real estate development and investment, contributing to Manhattan's density and vertical growth. It also supported the vibrant street life and cultural dynamics of the city, making neighborhoods accessible and interconnected.

Despite challenges such as traffic congestion and potential architectural homogeneity, the grid system remains a cornerstone of New York City's urban planning and expansion. Modern developments and sustainability initiatives integrate seamlessly with the grid, ensuring the city's continued adaptability and growth. Cultural landmarks like Times Square and Central Park benefit from the accessibility provided by the grid, cementing its role in the city's ongoing evolution. The grid system embodies a blend of historical wisdom and modern innovation, underpinning New York City's status as a global metropolis.

Reference: New York City's Grid Plan

2. Barcelona, Spain

The Eixample district in Barcelona, designed by Ildefons Cerdà in the mid-19th century, is a notable example of grid-based urban planning tailored to modern needs. Cerdà's plan introduced a grid of octagonal blocks, each side measuring approximately 113 meters, with chamfered corners to improve visibility and air circulation. This layout facilitated better traffic flow and reduced accidents at intersections, while wide, tree-lined streets and spacious blocks provided ample room for pedestrian movement and public amenities. The Eixample's design aimed to enhance the quality of life by integrating green spaces and promoting social interaction within a structured urban environment.

Cerdà's grid plan significantly influenced Barcelona's development, balancing residential, commercial, and cultural spaces within a coherent framework. The district's organized layout supports efficient land use and transportation, contributing to its vibrancy and livability. Despite the challenges of modern urban growth, the Eixample remains a key part of Barcelona, blending historical architecture with contemporary needs. The grid structure has enabled sustainable urban planning initiatives, ensuring the district's relevance and functionality in a rapidly evolving city. This design exemplifies how traditional urban planning principles can be adapted to meet the demands of modern urban living.

Reference: Eixample District Plan

3. Adelaide, Australia

Adelaide, known as the "City of Churches," is a prime example of grid-based urban planning, designed by Colonel William Light in the mid-19th century. The city's central business district (CBD) is laid out in a precise grid pattern, encompassing a square mile with wide streets and five central squares. This orderly layout is surrounded by a ring of parklands, providing a unique blend of urban and natural environments. Light's plan emphasized spaciousness, accessibility, and a high quality of life, incorporating ample green space within the urban fabric.

The grid system has facilitated Adelaide's growth and development, making it one of Australia's most navigable and livable cities. The straightforward grid pattern supports efficient transportation and urban management, while the surrounding parklands offer recreational opportunities and contribute to the city's aesthetic appeal. Adelaide's grid plan has successfully balanced the needs of residential, commercial, and public spaces, maintaining its historical charm while accommodating modern urban demands. This thoughtful design continues to underpin Adelaide's reputation as a well-organized, vibrant, and sustainable urban center.

Reference: Adelaide's Grid Plan

4. Chicago, USA

Chicago's grid system, established following the Great Chicago Fire of 1871, is a defining feature of the city's urban layout. The streets in central and northern Chicago are laid out in a precise grid pattern, with the zero point located at the intersection of State and Madison Streets. Each block typically measures 660 feet in length, aligning with the city's land survey system. This grid structure facilitated rapid urban expansion and efficient land use, supporting Chicago's growth into a major American metropolis.

The grid system simplifies navigation and enhances the provision of utilities and public services. It has allowed for organized and predictable real estate development, contributing to Chicago's distinctive skyline and diverse architectural styles. While the grid promotes ease of movement and planning, the city has also faced challenges such as traffic congestion. However, modern initiatives, including the introduction of bike lanes, pedestrian zones, and improved public transportation, continue to adapt the grid system to contemporary urban needs. Chicago's grid plan remains integral to its urban identity, balancing historical foundations with innovative urban solutions.

Reference: Chicago's Grid System

5. Brasília, Brazil

Brasília, the capital of Brazil, stands as a prominent example of modernist urban planning, designed by Oscar Niemeyer and Lúcio Costa in the 1950s. The city's layout, known as the 'Plano Piloto,' is distinctive for its resemblance to an airplane when viewed from above. This design, though not a traditional grid, incorporates principles of order and rationality. Residential and commercial blocks are systematically arranged along the "wings," while government buildings occupy the "cockpit," creating distinct zones for different urban functions.

The design aimed to symbolize Brazil's progress and modernity, emphasizing efficiency and organization. Wide avenues and spacious blocks facilitate smooth traffic flow and zoning, while ample green spaces and public areas promote social interaction and a high quality of life. The plan's rational layout supports efficient transportation and accessibility, contributing to Brasília's functionality as the administrative heart of the country.

Despite initial challenges related to its rapid development and somewhat impersonal scale, Brasília's urban plan has successfully accommodated its growing population and evolving urban needs. The city's design principles continue to influence its development, ensuring a balance between modern infrastructure and sustainable urban living. Brasília remains an iconic example of how modernist planning concepts can shape a city's identity and functionality, blending visionary design with practical urban solutions.

Reference: Brasília's Urban Plan

6. Philadelphia, USA

Philadelphia, one of the oldest cities in the United States, features a grid system that was designed by its founder, William Penn, in the late 17th century. Penn's vision for Philadelphia was to create a "greene countrie towne" that avoided the overcrowding and fire hazards prevalent in European cities of the time. His plan laid out a grid of streets intersecting at right angles, forming rectangular blocks, and included five central squares meant for public use, which provided open space and helped to manage urban growth.

The grid system facilitated efficient land division and navigation, making it easier to allocate plots for residential, commercial, and public purposes. The wide streets and regular block sizes contributed to a more orderly and accessible urban environment. This layout also supported the development of infrastructure and public services, fostering Philadelphia's growth as a major American city.

Philadelphia's grid plan set a precedent for future urban planning in the United States, influencing the design of other major cities. The grid structure has remained largely intact, allowing for both historic preservation and modern development. Despite the challenges of urban growth and modernization, the grid continues to support the city's infrastructure, transportation, and community life, maintaining Philadelphia's identity as a well-organized and historically rich urban center.

Reference: Philadelphia's Grid Plan

7. Portland, Oregon, USA

Portland, Oregon, is renowned for its well-planned grid system, which significantly contributes to its reputation as one of the most walkable and livable cities in the United States. The grid system, established in the mid-19th century, features notably small blocks, each measuring approximately 200 feet on each side. This compact block size is unique and sets Portland apart from other American cities.

Portland's grid plan was laid out by the city's founders, William Overton and Asa Lovejoy, in 1845. Their vision was to create a city that balanced urban growth with environmental sustainability and accessibility. The grid pattern was designed to facilitate easy navigation, efficient land use, and equitable access to urban amenities. The small blocks enhance walkability and connectivity, encouraging pedestrian movement and reducing the dominance of car traffic. This design promotes a vibrant street life, with frequent intersections that slow down vehicle speeds and make the streets safer for pedestrians and cyclists. The grid is complemented by wide streets and avenues, providing ample space for sidewalks, bike lanes, and green spaces.

The grid system's small blocks and wide streets have made Portland one of the most pedestrian-friendly cities in the country. This layout supports a vibrant urban environment, fostering community interaction and sustainable living. It also facilitates efficient public transportation, further reducing reliance on cars. Despite modern urban challenges, Portland's grid plan continues to promote a high quality of life, integrating historical urban planning principles with contemporary sustainability goals.

Reference: Portland's Urban Planning

8. Mexico City, Mexico

Mexico City's urban layout, particularly its historic center, combines ancient Aztec planning with Spanish colonial influences, featuring a distinct grid pattern. The city's grid system has roots in the ancient city of Tenochtitlán, which was laid out by the Aztecs before the Spanish conquest. After the conquest, the Spanish redesigned the city with a more formal grid plan, superimposing their urban design principles on the pre-existing layout.

The historic center, known as Centro Histórico, is characterized by a network of streets that intersect at right angles, creating a series of rectangular blocks. At the heart of this grid lies the Zócalo, one of the largest public squares in the world, which serves as a central hub for civic and cultural activities. Surrounding the Zócalo are important government buildings, cathedrals, and cultural institutions, reflecting the colonial emphasis on centralizing administrative and religious functions.

This grid system facilitated the organization of public and private spaces, supporting the city's administrative and commercial functions. The regularity of the grid made it easier to navigate and manage, which was particularly important in the rapidly growing colonial city. The grid layout also allowed for efficient land division and urban development, promoting orderly expansion and the establishment of a robust infrastructure.

Mexico City's grid remains an integral part of its urban fabric, balancing historical preservation with contemporary urban development. Despite the challenges of modern urban growth, such as traffic congestion and overpopulation, the grid system continues to support the city's infrastructure, transportation, and community life. The historic grid of Mexico City exemplifies how traditional urban planning principles can be adapted to meet the needs of a dynamic and evolving metropolis, ensuring its functionality and vibrancy in the modern era.

Reference: Mexico City's Urban Planning

9. Milton Keynes, England

Milton Keynes, a new town established in the 1960s in England, exemplifies modern British grid-based urban planning. The town was designed to address housing shortages and manage population overflows from London. Its planning aimed to combine the efficiency of a grid layout with the amenities of suburban living.

Milton Keynes was planned in 1967 with the goal of becoming a self-contained, sustainable urban area. The design was influenced by American grid systems and modernist principles, focusing on creating a functional and aesthetically pleasing urban environment. The town is structured around a grid of 1-kilometer-square blocks. Each block, or grid square, is a self-contained neighborhood with its own residential areas, schools, shops, and parks. Major roads run around the periphery of these blocks, facilitating smooth traffic flow and reducing congestion within neighborhoods.

This grid layout promotes efficient land use and transportation, making it easy for residents to access essential services and amenities. The design also incorporates ample green spaces, parks, and recreational areas, contributing to the high quality of life in Milton Keynes. The town's infrastructure supports sustainable living, with an emphasis on walkability, cycling paths, and public transportation. Despite challenges such as managing growth and maintaining infrastructure, Milton Keynes' grid-based urban planning remains a successful example of how modern urban design principles can create a balanced and livable city.

Reference: Milton Keynes Urban Planning

10. Ishikawa, Okinawa, Japan

Ishikawa, now part of Uruma in Okinawa, Japan, presents a unique example of grid-based urban planning, particularly notable for its post-World War II reconstruction. After the war, Ishikawa was rebuilt using a grid system, reflecting a blend of Japanese and Western urban planning principles.

The city's central area features a grid of rectangular blocks, designed to improve traffic flow and urban organization. This layout aimed to create a more orderly and navigable urban environment, contrasting with the more organic street patterns common in older Japanese cities. The grid system facilitated efficient land division, making it easier to allocate plots for residential, commercial, and public use.

The grid layout also supported the rapid reconstruction and development of infrastructure, essential for the city's recovery and growth. Wide streets and well-planned intersections improved accessibility and safety, while the regular block sizes allowed for efficient urban management. This planning approach helped Ishikawa to develop into a well-organized and functional urban area, balancing modern needs with traditional Japanese urban elements.

Despite the challenges of modern urban growth, Ishikawa's grid system continues to play a crucial role in its development. The layout supports sustainable urban living, with provisions for green spaces, pedestrian areas, and public transportation. Ishikawa's grid-based planning is a testament to the adaptability and resilience of urban design principles, ensuring the city's functionality and livability in the contemporary era.

Reference: Ishikawa Urban Planning

Conclusion

The Hippodamian Plan has left an enduring legacy on urban planning, influencing cities around the world. Its principles of order, rationality, and efficiency continue to shape modern urban landscapes, demonstrating the timeless relevance of Hippodamus's vision. Whether in ancient Greece or contemporary metropolises, the grid plan remains a testament to the enduring quest for structured and livable urban environments.

The Temple of Zeus at Stratos: The "Parthenon" of Western Greece

Ancient Stratos was built near the western bank of the Achelous River, on the border with Aetolia. The city served as the historical center of the Acarnanian League, akin to the Aetolian Thermon, and the sanctuary of Zeus was the religious and political hub for all Acarnanians.

The League was established in the 4th century BC, and during this time, the imposing temple of Zeus was constructed. An inscription discovered during excavations that indicated the temple's dedication to Zeus verified its dedication. The Acarnanian army would gather and camp beneath the hill and around the temple. The sanctuary of Zeus in Stratos was both a religious and political center for the Acarnanians.

Located at the northwestern edge of the acropolis, the temple of Stratius Zeus (protector god of the Stratians) is an illustrious Doric structure measuring 34.47 meters by 15.41 meters, with six columns on its narrow sides and eleven on its long sides. It was built between 321 and 312 BC, entirely from local hard limestone, but remained unfinished due to conflicts with the Aetolians.

The temple was divided into a cella, pronaos, and opisthodomos. The columns of the cella were placed close to its walls. With eight internal columns supporting the roof, it's likely that some of the cella was open-air. All the columns remained unfluted, suggesting the temple was never completed. The metopes were probably painted.

The temple served as the center for a federal cult, the powerful Acarnanian League. It was the fortified Acarnanian capital, meant to be showcased with a splendid temple. Indeed, the Temple of Stratius Zeus is one of the finest examples of 4th-century BC architecture.

This site confirms a historical federal cult of Zeus-Acheloos, which was not imaginary. Inscriptions show that it was a sacred location for the symbolic sale of slaves to grant them freedom. This means the site was a gathering place for worship, markets, and festivals. The Panacarnanians assembled here not only for religious reasons but also for federal decisions and needs.

The visible parts of the temple were made from gray, hard limestone sourced from the quarries of Lepenou, a village about 6 kilometers northwest of Stratos. Architectural elements of the temple, such as half-finished cylindrical columns and the temple's drum, were found in Lepenou, never having reached their destination.

To the southeast of the temple, there are the altar and bases of dedications. The first excavations of the temple took place between 1892 and 1913 and again in 1924 by the French Archaeological School, during which it was published along with the inscriptions found there. A. Orlandos published the most significant study and accurate restoration of the monument in 1925.

Common Mythological Motifs Between Typhon and Illuyanka

---

By Dimosthenis Vasiloudis

---

Myths of Chaos and Order: Exploring the Parallels Between Typhon and Illuyanka

The comparison between Typhon and Illuyanka reveals deep-rooted connections between Greek and Hittite mythologies. The seminal work by Walter Porzig in 1930, "Illuyankas and Typhon," drew significant attention to the striking parallels between these mythological figures, highlighting the shared themes and narrative structures that suggest a common background.

Typhon: The Greek Monstrous Challenge

Typhon, in Greek mythology, stands as one of the most formidable adversaries of the Olympian gods. According to Hesiod in "Theogony," Typhon was born from Gaia and Tartarus, intended to avenge the defeat of the Giants and Titans. His birth was a cataclysmic event, designed to disrupt the divine order established by Zeus. Typhon's challenge to Zeus represented the ultimate test of the Olympian ruler's authority, with the very cosmos hanging in the balance.

According to Hesiod, the conflict between Zeus and Typhon is a titanic struggle that shakes the very fabric of the universe. Zeus, armed with his thunderbolt, ultimately prevails, casting Typhon into Tartarus. This victory symbolizes the triumph of order over chaos, a recurrent theme in Greek mythology. Various sources, including Homer and later poets like Pindar and Aeschylus, expand on this myth, adding layers of complexity and regional variations to Typhon's narrative.

In alternative accounts, such as the one found in the "Homeric Hymn to Apollo," Typhon is presented as a son of Hera, produced in a cave in Cilicia. This version emphasizes Typhon's monstrous nature and his confinement in a liminal space, further associating him with the ancient and enigmatic forces that the Olympian gods sought to control. The motif of Zeus's temporary defeat and subsequent recovery of his "sinews" highlights the cyclical nature of myth, where even the greatest gods face challenges that reaffirm their power through overcoming adversity.

Illuyanka: The Hittite Serpent of Chaos

In Hittite mythology, Illuyanka is a serpentine dragon that embodies chaos and disorder, much like Typhon. The myth of Illuyanka, preserved in cuneiform tablets found at Hattusa, the Hittite capital, unfolds in two primary versions. Both versions involve the storm god Tarhunna (or Teshub) facing and ultimately overcoming Illuyanka, often with the aid of trickery and assistance from other deities.

In the first version, Tarhunna, after an initial defeat, seeks the help of the goddess Inara. She devises a plan involving a banquet to lure Illuyanka out of his lair, enabling Tarhunna to bind and kill the dragon. This narrative echoes the Greek myth in its depiction of the storm god's struggle against a serpentine embodiment of chaos, requiring not only brute strength but also cunning to achieve victory.

The second version introduces the motif of bodily mutilation and restoration, with Illuyanka stealing Tarhunna's eyes and heart. Tarhunna's son, born to a mortal woman, marries Illuyanka's daughter and retrieves the stolen organs as part of a marriage arrangement. This version culminates in a final battle where Tarhunna, now restored, kills Illuyanka but at the cost of his son's life, adding a tragic dimension to the myth. This motif of bodily dismemberment and recovery parallels Zeus's temporary loss of power to Typhon and the subsequent restoration facilitated by allies, emphasizing the themes of sacrifice and regeneration.

The sky god kills the dragon, Illuyanka. Behind him is his son, Sarruma. The twisting body of the snake is depicted in undulating lines with human figures sliding along Museum of Anatolian Civilizations, Ankara, Turkey

Georges Jansoone self-photographed

Shared Themes and Narrative Structures

The myths of Typhon and Illuyanka exhibit several shared motifs that suggest a common mythological framework. Both Typhon and Illuyanka represent primal chaos, challenging the divine order established by the storm gods, Zeus and Tarhunna. The struggle between these gods and their serpentine adversaries symbolizes the perennial conflict between order and chaos, a theme prevalent in many mythological traditions.

One significant motif is the initial defeat of the storm god, which underscores the formidable nature of the adversary and sets the stage for a dramatic comeback. In both myths, the storm god requires assistance to overcome the chaos monster—Zeus receives help from Hermes and Aegipan, while Tarhunna is aided by Inara and Hupasiyas. This collaborative effort highlights the interconnectedness of divine forces in maintaining cosmic order.

Another common element is the use of trickery and cunning to defeat the monster. In the Hittite myth, Inara's banquet lures Illuyanka into a vulnerable position, while in the Greek myth, Zeus's allies help him regain his sinews. This theme of cunning complementing strength underscores the multifaceted nature of divine power.

The motif of bodily mutilation and restoration is also prominent. Illuyanka's theft of Tarhunna's eyes and heart and their subsequent recovery mirror Typhon's temporary incapacitation of Zeus by removing his sinews. The restoration of these vital organs or powers symbolizes the reestablishment of order and the resilience of the divine order against chaos.

---

The Multilingual Bogazköy Archive: Over 25,000 Cuneiform Tablets Containing 8 Different Languages!

---

Influence and Interpretation

The parallels between Typhon and Illuyanka have significant implications for understanding the transmission and transformation of mythological themes across cultures. The close similarities suggest a shared mythological heritage rooted in ancient traditions, reflecting common concerns and cosmological views.

Walter Burkert and Calvert Watkins have extensively studied these connections, also highlighting the Indo-European poetic formulas that underpin these myths. Watkins, in his work "How to Kill a Dragon," reconstructs the underlying narrative structures that reveal a deep-seated cultural continuity between Greek and Hittite myths. These studies illuminate the ways in which mythological motifs were adapted and transformed to fit the specific cultural and religious contexts of the Greeks and Hittites.

The influence of Near Eastern mythologies on Greek myth, particularly in the context of Typhon and Illuyanka, underscores the dynamic interplay of cultural exchange in the ancient world. The geographic and cultural interactions between the Hellenes and the Hittites, facilitated by regions such as Cilicia, provided fertile ground for the blending and reinterpretation of mythological themes. This cross-cultural fertilization enriches our understanding of ancient mythologies as interconnected rather than isolated traditions.

The comparison between Typhon and Illuyanka reveals a tapestry of shared mythological motifs that transcend cultural boundaries. The narratives of these monstrous adversaries reflect deep-seated themes of order versus chaos, divine struggle, and the resilience of cosmic order. Through the detailed examination of these myths, scholars like Walter Porzig, Walter Burkert, and Calvert Watkins have illuminated the intricate connections between Greek and Hittite mythologies, offering a glimpse into the shared heritage of Near Eastern mythological traditions.

These myths, rich in narrative complexity and symbolic depth, continue to captivate and inform our understanding of ancient cultures. They remind us of the universal human fascination with the forces that shape our world and the enduring power of myth to convey profound truths about the human experience.

A Ground-Breaking Discovery: The Earliest Ship Ever Found in the Deep Seas!

A 3,300-year-old ship’s cargo with hundreds of intact amphorae discovered 90 km from shore at a depth of 1.8 km on the Mediterranean Sea floor.

A ship’s cargo from 3,300—3,400 years ago, with hundreds of intact vessels, was found at the incredible depth of 1.8 kilometers on the Mediterranean Sea floor. The cargo was found during a standard survey executed by Energean - E&P natural gas company, who operates the Karish, Karish North, Katlan and Tanin offshore fields near Israel. The contents were positively identified as Late Bronze Age Canaanite storage vessels by the Israel Antiquities Authority.

Jacob Sharvit, Head of the Israel Antiquities Authority Marine Unit, explains, “The ship seems to have sunk in crisis, either due to a storm or to an attempted piracy attack – a well-known occurrence in the Late Bronze Age. This is both the first and the oldest ship found in the Eastern Mediterranean deep sea, ninety kilometers from the nearest shore. This is a world-class history-changing discovery: This find reveals to us as never before the ancient mariners’ navigational skills – capable of traversing the Mediterranean Sea without a line of sight to any coast. From this geographical point, only the horizon is visible all around. To navigate they probably used the celestial bodies, by taking sightings and angles of the sun and star positions.”

“As part of our ongoing activity to discover and extract natural gas from the deep sea, we conduct surveys that check different parameters, using an advanced submersible robot to scour the seafloor,” says Dr. Karnit Bahartan, Head of the Environmental Staff at Energean. “About a year ago, during a survey, we saw the unusual sight of what seemed to be a large pile of jugs heaped on the seafloor. We are in ongoing contact with the Israel Antiquities Authority, and when we sent them the images it turned out to be a sensational discovery, far beyond what we could imagine.”

In light of this discovery’s tremendous importance Energean rose to the occasion and dedicated a team to work together with Israel Antiquities Authority experts to closely investigate the boat, using their “Energean Star” ship equipped to conduct deep-sea work. The company’s technicians planned a unique, complex operation and even built a special tool to enable extracting artifacts with minimal risk of damage to the entire assemblage.

“The robot’s survey and mapping of the site clarified this to be a sunken ship ca. 12-14 meters long that was transporting hundreds of vessels, of which only some are visible above the ocean floor. The muddy bottom conceals a second layer of vessels, and it seems that wooden beams of the ship are also buried within the mud,” says Sharvit.

In the course of two days of work at sea, the Energean team extracted two vessels, each from a different extremity of the ship, to minimize disturbances to the intact assemblage of the boat and its cargo.

“The vessel type identified in the cargo was designed as the most efficient means of transporting relatively cheap and mass-produced products such as oil, wine and other agricultural products such as fruit. Finding such a great quantity of amphorae on board one single ship is testimony to significant commercial ties between their country of origin and the ancient Near Eastern lands on the Mediterranean coast”, says Sharvit.

He adds: “This is a truly sensational find. Only two other shipwrecks with cargo are known from the Late Bronze Age in the Mediterranean Sea – the boat from Cape Gelidonya and the Uluburun boat; both found off the Turkish coast. Yet both of those shipwrecks were found relatively near the shore, and were accessible using normal diving equipment. Based on these two finds, the academic assumption until now was that trade in that time was executed by safely flitting from port to port, hugging the coastline within eye contact.

The discovery of this boat now changes our entire understanding of ancient mariner abilities: It is the very first to be found at such a great distance with no line of sight to any landmass. There is tremendous potential here for research: The ship is preserved at such a great depth that time has frozen since the moment of disaster – its body and contexts have not been disturbed by human hand (divers, fishermen, etc.); nor affected by waves and currents which do impact shipwrecks in shallower waters.”

Shaul Zemach, Energean Israel CEO, addresses the company’s decision to execute such a complicated operation to extract archaeological artifacts from the ocean floor: “The ongoing relationship with the Israel Antiquities Authority is an inseparable element of Energean’s connection to the community, and exemplifies our commitment to society and to the environment. In this complex project our team exhibited extraordinary professionalism, and we are happy to be partners to a discovery of this magnitude.”

Eli Escusido, Israel Antiquities Authority Director, says, “The important significance of these finds prompted a decision to exhibit these Canaanite vessels extracted from the seafloor, and to thus tell the public the story of this boat, in the framework of opening the Archaeological Campus for “sample taste” tours this summer. These visits will afford people a glimpse of this unique edifice, its mosaics and laboratories, even before the official opening of our expansive visitor center, currently scheduled two years from today. I earnestly thank Energean for their alertness in identifying this ancient cargo, and for dedicating the resources which have already enabled initial understandings gleaned from this rare shipwreck.”

Israel Antiquities Authority 

The Enigmatic 9,000-Year-Old Cave Painting in Tassili Cave, Algeria

A Glimpse into Ancient Psychedelic Practices

9000-year-old cave painting in Tassili cave, Algeria. Depicting a shaman during psychedelic mushroom use.

Deep within the rugged landscapes of the Sahara Desert lies a treasure trove of prehistoric art that has captivated archaeologists and historians for decades. The Tassili n'Ajjer cave complex in southeastern Algeria, a UNESCO World Heritage site, is renowned for its rich collection of rock art. Among these, a particular painting estimated to be around 9,000 years old stands out due to its intriguing depiction of a shaman engaged in what appears to be the use of psychedelic mushrooms. This extraordinary artwork provides a rare window into the spiritual and cultural practices of ancient hunter-gatherer societies.

The Tassili n'Ajjer: A Prehistoric Canvas

The Tassili n'Ajjer plateau stretches over 72,000 square kilometers and boasts more than 15,000 engravings and paintings. These artworks chronicle the lives, beliefs, and environments of the people who once inhabited this region. The cave paintings span several millennia, with some of the oldest dating back to around 12,000 years ago. They offer a visual narrative of the transition from a lush, verdant landscape to the arid desert we see today.

Discovery and Interpretation

The shamanic painting in question was first documented by French archaeologist Henri Lhote during his expeditions in the 1950s. Lhote and his team were struck by the vividness and complexity of the imagery, which included human figures, animals, and enigmatic symbols. The depiction of the shaman, however, has garnered particular attention due to the distinct presence of mushrooms and the associated trance-like postures.

In the painting, the shaman is adorned with elaborate headgear and body paint, common indicators of a ritualistic or ceremonial role. Surrounding the figure are representations of mushrooms, which appear to be of the Psilocybe genus—known for their psychoactive properties. The shaman's posture and facial expression suggest an altered state of consciousness, a hallmark of shamanic journeys facilitated by the consumption of psychedelic substances.

Shamanism and Psychedelics in Prehistoric Cultures

Shamanism is one of the oldest spiritual practices known to humanity, with evidence dating back tens of thousands of years. Central to shamanic traditions is the belief in the ability to access otherworldly realms and communicate with spiritual entities. Psychedelic plants and fungi have played a significant role in these practices, serving as catalysts for trance states and visionary experiences.

The use of psychoactive substances by ancient shamans is well-documented across various cultures. For instance, the indigenous peoples of the Americas have long utilized peyote, ayahuasca, and psilocybin mushrooms in their rituals. The Tassili painting suggests that similar practices existed in North Africa, highlighting a broader, possibly global, prehistoric tradition of using psychedelics for spiritual purposes.

The Symbolism of the Tassili Shaman

The Tassili shaman's depiction is rich in symbolic meaning. The elaborate headdress and body paint likely signify the shaman's elevated status within the community. The presence of mushrooms, depicted with careful detail, emphasizes their importance in the ritual. The trance-like state of the shaman points to a journey beyond the physical realm, a common theme in shamanic practices where the practitioner seeks guidance, healing, or knowledge from the spirit world.

The painting also reflects a deep connection between humans and nature, where natural elements like mushrooms are revered not merely as food but as sacred tools. This reverence underscores a worldview in which all aspects of nature are imbued with spiritual significance, a perspective that is often lost in modern times.

Implications and Insights

The 9,000-year-old painting from Tassili n'Ajjer is more than an artistic marvel; it is a testament to the sophisticated spiritual life of ancient peoples. It challenges contemporary assumptions about prehistoric societies, revealing their complex belief systems and the profound role of psychedelics in their culture.

Moreover, this artwork provides invaluable insights into the origins of religious and spiritual practices. It suggests that the quest for transcendence and the use of natural substances to achieve it are deeply rooted in human history. As modern science continues to explore the therapeutic potentials of psychedelics, this ancient painting serves as a reminder of their long-standing significance in human spirituality.

The shamanic cave painting in Tassili n'Ajjer is a powerful reminder of the depth and richness of our prehistoric heritage. It opens a window into a world where art, spirituality, and nature were intimately intertwined. As we continue to study and interpret these ancient symbols, we gain not only a better understanding of our ancestors but also a renewed appreciation for the enduring mysteries of the human spirit.

Archaeological Breakthrough: The Discovery of Late Bronze Age Mycenaean Purple-Dye Production at Cape Kolonna, Aegina

A groundbreaking study published in PLOS ONE on June 12, 2024, sheds new light on the intricate processes of purple-dye production during the Late Bronze Age. This study by Lydia Berger and colleagues provides in-depth archaeological, analytical, and procedural insights into the manufacture of this priceless dye at Cape Kolonna, Aegina.

Introduction

The island of Aegina, located in the Saronic Gulf, has long been recognized for its significant cultural and economic contributions throughout history. The recent excavations in the Eastern Suburb of Bronze Age Aegina Kolonna have unveiled remarkable evidence of purple-dye production, dating back to the Early Mycenaean period (16th century BC). This study goes into great detail about the archaeological finds, such as mollusk shells, ceramic sherds with pigment residues, and functional buildings. Together, these things give us a full picture of the dye-making methods used during this time.

Orthophoto of Aegina Kolonna with Area K10 in the Bronze Age Outer Suburb marked in red.

Archaeological Context

The research focused on a small area in the Eastern Suburb, designated as Area K10. Excavations revealed two superimposed Early Mycenaean buildings, destroyed and buried one above the other. Among the debris, researchers found clear evidence of a domestic context intertwined with various craft activities, prominently including the production of purple dye.

Evidence of Dye Production

The standout findings from Area K10 include ceramic fragments with purple pigment residues, high concentrations of mollusk shells, and specialized tools. Chemical analysis using High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC) identified the banded dye-murex (Hexaplex trunculus) as the primary source of the dye. This species was preferred for its high content of monobromoindigotin (MBI) and the desired purple shade it produced. Additionally, the presence of crushing tools and a dedicated waste pit underscores the organized and possibly professional nature of dye production at this site.

Selection of crushed purple snail shells from the pit in Area K10.

Technological and Ritual Aspects

The study highlights not only the technical aspects but also the potential ritual significance of purple-dye production. The skeletal remains of heavily burned juvenile animals found within the workshop area suggest ritualistic practices possibly aimed at safeguarding or sanctifying the dye production process. This aligns with the broader understanding of Mycenaean society, where complex rituals were often intertwined with significant economic activities.

Purple pigment sample KOL-01 (from fragment SE16/15-K10-85-03). Photo by L. Berger.

Conclusion

This research marks a significant advancement in our understanding of Late Bronze Age technologies and economic practices. A thorough study of the archaeological and bioarchaeological evidence from Cape Kolonna reveals important information about how purple dye was made and what it meant to people in ancient Aegina. The findings not only enrich our knowledge of Mycenaean craft and trade but also open new avenues for exploring the socio-economic dynamics of ancient Mediterranean societies.

For further details, refer to the full study in PLOS ONE More than just a color: Archaeological, analytical, and procedural aspects of Late Bronze Age purple-dye production at Cape Kolonna, Aegina, page 1.

The Ancient Greek City of Tralles Combats Immorality: Measures Against Licentious Living

In an intriguing discovery from the ancient city of Tralles, modern Aydın, a Greek decree has been unearthed that sheds light on the city's efforts to combat immorality in the 2nd century A.D. The decree, inscribed on a marble stele, was found reused in the northern wall of the "Kuzey Dükkanları" (Northern Shops), a structure dating back to Late Antiquity (5th–7th century A.D.). This artifact provides a fascinating glimpse into the societal and legal measures employed by the citizens of Tralleis to maintain public decency and order.

The decree was proposed by various city officials, including the secretary of the people and the council. It begins by emphasizing the city's longstanding commitment to a moral and orderly way of life, inherited from their ancestors, who had ordered the city through pure laws and customs. The officials lament the recent rise in shameless behaviors that threaten the moral fabric of the city. They particularly focus on individuals who publicly exhibit their licentious lifestyles, making no effort to conceal their actions.

In response to these concerns, the city officials resolved to bar these licentious individuals from accessing public sanctuaries and gymnasiums. This measure reflects the broader societal commitment to maintaining public decency and order. The decree specifically targets those living an "unnatural" sexual lifestyle, referred to as οἱ ἐν κιναιδείᾳ β̣ιοῦντες, a term used to describe men exhibiting effeminate behavior, often associated with male prostitution.

The exclusion of these individuals from public spaces was seen as essential to preserving the city's dignity and moral standards. The decree's language is deliberately guarded, avoiding explicit terms for sexual behaviors, which were considered inappropriate for public inscriptions. This careful wording underscores the sensitivity of the issue and the desire to address it without offending public sensibilities.

This measure is part of a broader strategy to uphold public order and decency. The decree also mentions the routine removal of female prostitutes from public streets to less visible areas, ensuring that their presence does not disturb the city's virtue. This practice reflects a consistent approach to handling licentious behavior in ancient Greek cities, similar to laws in Classical Athens, where male prostitutes were also banned from public sanctuaries and gymnasia.

The study of this decree provides a detailed look at how Tralleis addressed issues of public morality through legislative measures. By barring individuals living licentious lifestyles from public spaces, the city aimed to uphold the moral standards and dignity of its citizens. This decree highlights a deeply rooted commitment to orderly conduct and the preservation of public decency.

The discovery and analysis of this inscription offer valuable insights into the societal norms and legal practices of ancient Tralleis. It underscores the city's efforts to combat immorality and maintain a well-ordered society, reflecting broader trends in ancient Greek approaches to public morality.

The Genealogy of Alexander the Great: Greek or NOT?

The Genealogy of Alexander the Great: Historical and Literary Evidence

The purpose of this study is to contribute to the research of the genealogy of Alexander the Great, aiming to gather and analyze historical and literary evidence supporting the claims of his origins. This research utilizes material from ancient Greek literature, works of Greek Patrology, and other historical texts, thereby offering a comprehensive view of Alexander's lineage.

Sources and Methodology

The sources for this study include a diverse range of ancient writings:

• Ancient Greek literature: Herodotus, Thucydides, Theopompus, Diodorus Siculus, and Plutarch.

• Greek Patrology: S. Theophylii Antiocheni and Eusebii Caesariencis.

• Corpus Scriptorum Historiae Byzantinae (CSHB): George Syncellus.

• Papyrology: Bernard P. Grenfel and Arthur S. Hunt’s “Hellenica Oxyrhynchiacum Theopompi et Cratippi Fragmentis”.

• Corpus Scriptorum Latinorum (CSL): Pompeius Trogus (via Iustinus' epitome).

• Tertullian’s “On the Soul” containing a fragment from Ephorus.

• Arrian’s “Anabasis of Alexander”.

The methodology involved textual criticism and a meticulous study of these texts to validate the historical and literary claims regarding Alexander’s genealogy.

Findings

Herodotus' Accounts: Herodotus (5th century BC) in “Persian Wars” describes Alexander I, an ancestor of Alexander the Great, as a descendant of Temenus from Argos in Peloponnese. Herodotus recounts the journey of three brothers, descendants of Temenus, from Argos to Illyria and then to Macedonia, where they established the Macedonian dynasty. Alexander I himself claimed Greek descent in his declaration to the Greek army before the battle of Plataeae.

Thucydides and Theopompus: Thucydides (5th century BC) in “History of the Peloponnesian War” confirms the Temenid origin of the Macedonian kings. Theopompus (4th century BC) in “Philippica” also traces the lineage back to Heracles through Temenus.

Diodorus Siculus' Contributions: Diodorus Siculus (1st century BC) in “Library of History” asserts that Alexander was a descendant of Heracles on his father’s side and of the Aeacids on his mother’s side. Diodorus’ fragments further trace the genealogy of Macedonian kings from Caranus to Alexander, reinforcing the Heraclid lineage.

Latin Sources: Iustinus, summarizing Pompeius Trogus, mentions Caranus leading Greeks to Macedonia and establishing the dynasty. Tertullian preserves a fragment from Ephorus, suggesting symbolic prophecies about Alexander's birth.

Plutarch and Arrian: Plutarch (1st-2nd century AD) in “Parallel Lives – Alexander and Caesar” states that Alexander’s lineage is well accepted as being descended from Heracles and Aeacus. Arrian (1st-2nd century AD) in “Anabasis of Alexander” reiterates Alexander’s own declarations about his divine and heroic ancestry.

Greek Patrology and Byzantine Sources: Theophylii Antiocheni and Eusebii Caesariencis provide genealogical accounts linking Alexander back to Heracles. George Syncellus in “Chronographiae” maintains this genealogy and even mentions alternative, though less credible, theories about Alexander’s parentage.

Analysis

The consistency across these sources lends significant credibility to the genealogical claims. Herodotus and Thucydides provide early accounts that are further corroborated by later historians like Diodorus and Plutarch. The use of textual criticism ensures that these ancient writings are interpreted accurately.

The study also addresses the so-called “Macedonic question,” asserting that the genealogical evidence predates these debates and thus remains unaffected by them.

The genealogical evidence strongly supports that Alexander the Great was of Greek origin, descending from Heracles and Aeacus. The various historical texts, analyzed through textual criticism, provide a coherent and credible lineage. As Plutarch states, Alexander's ancestry is accepted "without any question," solidifying his Greek heritage through both his paternal and maternal lines. This research contributes to the historical understanding of one of history's most significant figures, affirming his place within the Greek legacy.

Alexander the Great Family Tree

Source: researchgate

References:

1. Herodotus, The Persian Wars, translated by A. D. Godley. Loeb Classical

Library. Harvard University Press. 1926

2. Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War, translated by C. F. Smith. Loeb

Classical Library. Harvard University Press. 1928

3. Grenfell, Bernard Pyne., et Arturus Hunt, Hellenica Oxyrhynchia cum

Theopompi et Cratippi Fragmentis, Oxonii M.DCCCC.IX

4. Diodorus Siculus, Library of History, translated by C. H. Oldfather. Loeb

Classical Library. Harvard University Press. 1935

5. Marcus Junianus Justinus, Epitome of the Philippic History of Pompeius

Trogus, translated by the Rev. John Selby Watson, London, 1853. Corpus

Scriptorum Latinorum, a digital library of Latin Literature.

6. Plutarch (Plutarchus), Lives – Alexander and Caesar, translated by Bernadotte

Perrin. Loeb Classcal Library. Harvard University Press. 1919

7. Saint Theophyli Episcopi Antiocheni, Ad Autolycum lib. II, Patrologiae,

Cursus Completus, Series Graeca, v.6, J. -P. Migne, 1857.

8. Eusebii Pamphili Caesariensis Episcopi, Chronicorum Lib. I-II, Patrologiae,

Cursus Completus, Series Graeca, v. 19, J. -P. Migne, 1857.

9. Georgii Syncelli, Chronographiae, in Corpus Scriptorum Historiae

Byzantinae(CSHB), Georgius Syngellus et Nicephorus CP.,v.1, consilio

B.G.Niebuhrii, ex recensione G. Dindorfil. Bonnae,Impensis ed. Weberi,

M.DCCCXX.IX.

10.Ephorus – Palaifatus, Complete Works. Editions “Cactos”, 2001. Athens

(Greece).

11.Documenta Catholica Omnia – Multilingual Catholic E – Books Database,

Tertullianus – On the soul, translated by Peter Holmes D.D.

12. Mysliwiec, Karol, The twilight of ancient Egypt: first millenium B.C.E., p.

169. Cornell University Press. 2000.

13. “The Anabasis of Alexander; or, The history of the wars and conquests of

Alexander the Great. Literally translated, with a commentary, from the Greek

of Arrian, the Nicomedian”. By E. J. Chinnock, M.A., LL.B., LOND9N,

Rector of Dumfries Academy, Hodder and Stoughton, 27, Paternoster Row,

London. Butler & Tanner. The selwood works. Frome and London.

MDCCCLXXXIV. Cornell University Library PA 3935. E5A3 1884.

14. Carol. and Theod. Mulleri, Fragmenta Historicorum Graecorum. Editore

Ambrosio Firmin Didot. Parisiis MDCCCXLI.

15. Paul Kroh, Lexicon der Antiken Auctorem, Alfred Kröner Verlag, Stuttgart.

Translated in Greek by D. Lipurlis – L. Tromaras. University Studio Press.

The Sweet Track: Unveiling a 5830-Year-Old Neolithic Engineering Marvel

In the heart of the Somerset Levels in England lies one of the most remarkable archaeological discoveries of the 20th century: the Sweet Track. This ancient timber walkway, unearthed in 1970, dates back 5830 years to the Neolithic period. It stands as a testament to the ingenuity and resilience of our ancestors, who devised innovative solutions to traverse the challenging marshy landscapes.

Discovery and Significance

The Sweet Track was discovered in 1970 by John Coles and Bryony Coles during routine peat extraction activities. Its discovery was not only significant due to its age but also because of its exemplary state of preservation. Named after Ray Sweet, the peat digger who first identified the timbers, the Sweet Track offers a rare glimpse into the engineering capabilities and daily life of Neolithic communities.

Construction and Purpose

The trackway was constructed using oak, ash, and lime timbers, which were felled and split using stone tools. These wooden planks were then laid across the marshy ground, supported by pairs of upright stakes driven into the peat. This innovative construction provided a stable and dry passage across the waterlogged terrain, allowing for easier movement of people and goods.

A digital model of the Avalon Marshes area has been formed, allowing this journey along the 5,830 year old Neolithic Sweet Track to be recreated. Two versions are available, one with and one without subtitles. Both have commentary.

The Sweet Track was part of a larger network of trackways, indicating that the inhabitants of the Somerset Levels had developed an extensive infrastructure to navigate their environment. This network likely facilitated trade, social interaction, and access to resources across the region.

Engineering and Design

The design of the Sweet Track is a marvel of Neolithic engineering. The choice of durable hardwoods and the method of construction demonstrate a deep understanding of the local environment and materials. The timber planks, some over a meter long, were meticulously shaped and joined to create a continuous and resilient pathway. The upright stakes, driven deep into the peat, provided the necessary stability to withstand the shifting and waterlogged ground.

Archaeological Insights

The excavation of the Sweet Track has provided valuable insights into Neolithic society. Tools and artifacts discovered along the trackway suggest that it was used regularly, likely forming an integral part of the daily lives of the people who built it. Pollen analysis and other environmental data have revealed details about the surrounding landscape, indicating a mixed environment of woodland, wetlands, and open water.

Moreover, the Sweet Track has contributed to our understanding of prehistoric woodworking techniques. The precision with which the timbers were cut and fitted together indicates a high level of craftsmanship and knowledge of carpentry. The use of stone tools to shape the wood showcases the adaptability and skill of Neolithic builders.

Preservation and Legacy

The peat bogs of the Somerset Levels played a crucial role in the preservation of the Sweet Track. The anaerobic conditions of the peat prevented the wood from decaying, allowing it to survive for millennia. Modern preservation techniques have been employed to ensure that the trackway remains intact for future generations to study and appreciate.

Today, the Sweet Track is a symbol of human ingenuity and resilience. It serves as a reminder of our ancestors' ability to adapt to and manipulate their environment to meet their needs. The trackway is a valuable cultural and historical artifact, shedding light on the complex and resourceful societies of the Neolithic era.

The discovery of the Sweet Track in 1970 opened a window into the past, revealing the advanced engineering and societal structures of Neolithic communities. This 5830-year-old timber walkway is more than just a path across the marshes; it is a testament to the innovation and perseverance of our ancestors. As we continue to study and preserve this ancient marvel, the Sweet Track remains a source of inspiration and a key to understanding the ingenuity of early human civilization.

Divergence Patterns in Indo-European Language Family: Trees, Waves, and Network Analysis

---

Based on the study entitled Splits or waves? Trees or webs? How divergence measures and network analysis can unravel language histories

---

Same Languages, Different Visions

In exploring the divergence of languages within a family, linguists traditionally use models such as 'splits' and 'waves.' The 'splits' model is akin to a branching tree, where languages diverge distinctly from a common ancestor, while the 'wave' model represents a more interconnected dialect continuum. This study illustrates the difference between these models using the Indo-European language family. Figures 1 and 2 depict trees with clear binary splits, while Figures 3 and 4 present a NeighborNet analysis showing a web of cross-cutting relationships. These contrasting representations highlight the complexity of language divergence and reflect different historical processes.

View fullsize

Figure 1.

View fullsize

Figure 2.

View fullsize

Figure 3.

View fullsize

Figure 4.

The tree models suggest distinct separations between speaker populations, often through migrations. Conversely, the wave model indicates expansions over continuous territories where dialects overlap and influence each other. The study emphasizes that real-world language histories often involve both processes, requiring models that can integrate tree-like and web-like signals. Phylogenetic network methods, such as those discussed in this paper, offer a means to capture this complexity. They combine elements of both models, providing a more accurate reflection of the historical divergence of languages.

Language Divergence and the Real World: Two Models, One Reality

The splits and wave models reflect two different real-world processes. The split model corresponds to populations dividing and migrating away from each other, leading to distinct language branches. The wave model represents populations expanding over contiguous territories, maintaining local contact and resulting in overlapping dialects. Understanding these processes is crucial for interpreting the historical relationships between languages within a family. Real-world factors such as demographic movements, socio-political changes, and cultural interactions are the primary drivers of language divergence.

---

This Is The Most Sophisticated Model For Indo-European Language Relationships

---

The study stresses that language divergence patterns are direct reflections of these historical processes. Linguistic changes occur naturally, but the extent to which these changes spread or remain isolated depends on the real-world context. For example, vast expansions, such as those driven by the Roman Empire, created the Romance language family, while isolated groups like the Albanians and Armenians developed independently. Borrowing and contact between languages further complicate the divergence patterns, as seen in scenarios where initial splits are followed by later interactions. This complexity necessitates models that can distinguish between splits and waves and accurately represent the intertwined nature of language histories.

Network Methods: Best of Both Worlds?

Network methods, particularly the Network algorithm and NeighborNet, are effective in capturing both split-like and wave-like signals within language divergence data. Developed initially for biological sciences, these methods have been adapted for linguistic studies. Network takes individual state data, focusing on specific linguistic changes, while NeighborNet uses overall measures of distance between languages. Both methods can represent the mixed nature of language divergence, combining elements of tree-like branching and web-like continua.

Figure 5.

Unrooted network of 19 Germanic language samples. (Reproduced with permission from Forster et al. 2006, p. 134.)

The Network algorithm, for example, has been applied to limited datasets of Celtic and Germanic languages, demonstrating its potential to represent complex relationships. NeighborNet, on the other hand, has been used with various linguistic datasets, including phonetic divergence measures for Germanic languages. These network methods reveal patterns that align well with known historical contexts, such as the clear splits between English and continental Germanic varieties and the web-like patterns within regional dialects. Despite some limitations, such as the placement of intermediate dialects, network methods provide a nuanced view of language divergence that tree-only models cannot achieve.

View fullsize

Figure 6.

View fullsize

Figure 7.

Measuring Network Versus Tree Signals

Both Network and NeighborNet can effectively visualize the strengths of tree-like and web-like signals within language divergence data. Network identifies individual linguistic changes within the network diagram, providing a detailed view of specific innovations and retentions. NeighborNet, while using distance measures, captures the overall balance between branching and continuum patterns, reflecting the mixed nature of real-world language histories. These methods allow researchers to assess the degree of tree-ness or net-ness in a dataset, providing insights into the historical processes that shaped language divergence.

For example, NeighborNet analyses of Germanic languages show clear splits corresponding to historical separations, such as the isolation of English varieties, while also depicting the continuum of dialects across continental West Germanic. These patterns align with known historical expansions and migrations, demonstrating the utility of network methods in capturing the complexity of language divergence. By integrating tree-like and web-like signals, network methods offer a more comprehensive representation of language histories, accommodating the multifaceted nature of linguistic evolution.

State Versus Distance Data: Theory and Practice

The study compares state data, which focus on specific linguistic changes, and distance data, which measure overall divergence between languages. Network methods like the Network algorithm use state data to identify individual changes, while NeighborNet employs distance measures to represent the overall divergence pattern. Both approaches have their strengths and limitations. State data provide detailed insights into specific innovations, but distance measures can capture the broader divergence pattern, reflecting the combined impact of all linguistic changes.

NeighborNet analyses of Germanic languages, for example, reveal patterns that correspond well to known historical contexts, such as the separation of English varieties and the continuum within continental West Germanic. These results demonstrate that distance measures can effectively represent language divergence, even without specifying ancestral states. The study proposes that the randomness of parallel innovations and shared retentions ensures that their effects balance out, leaving the non-random patterns of shared innovations to dominate the overall divergence pattern. This principle explains why distance measures can reflect language histories accurately, supporting the use of network methods in linguistic research.

Lessons for Historical Linguistic Methodology

The study emphasizes the need for balanced approaches that integrate both state and distance data, as well as tree-only and network methods, to uncover the full complexity of language histories. While tree models are useful for specific purposes, such as dating language divergence, network methods provide a more comprehensive representation of the mixed nature of linguistic evolution. By capturing both split-like and wave-like signals, network methods offer valuable insights into the historical processes that shaped language divergence.

The application of these methods to Germanic languages demonstrates their effectiveness in reflecting known historical contexts, suggesting their utility for probing the early divergence history of other language families, such as Indo-European. The study highlights the importance of considering real-world factors, such as demographic movements and socio-political changes, in interpreting language divergence patterns. By integrating these factors, network methods can provide a more accurate and nuanced view of language histories, enhancing our understanding of linguistic evolution and prehistory.

Turkey Completes Comprehensive Digital Scan of Hagia Sophia

The Turkish Ministry of Culture and Tourism has successfully completed a meticulous digital scan of Hagia Sophia, producing an exact "digital twin" of the iconic monument. This endeavor is part of a broader initiative to establish a comprehensive "holistic record" of the historic site, as reported by Turkish state broadcaster TRT Haber.

Initiated in 2022, the project utilized cutting-edge scanning technologies to capture high-resolution data of Hagia Sophia. The resulting digital model has been meticulously archived in a specialized database. This digital twin ensures that in the event of an earthquake or other disasters leading to partial collapse, the monument can be reconstructed with precision, preserving its original form and integrity, according to TRT Haber.

---

Archaeologists Call On Unesco To Protect The Hagia Sophia

---

Beyond the creation of the digital twin, the project has also contributed to the academic study of Hagia Sophia. Numerous scholarly papers and books detailing the construction and history of the monument have been published and included in the database. These academic contributions offer in-depth insights into the current condition of Hagia Sophia, aiding in its preservation. The data gathered facilitates protective measures that do not compromise the monument's historic attributes or its outstanding structural quality.

---

The Hagia Sophia Will Collapse If It Is Not Closed, A Turkish Professor Warns

---

This initiative underscores Türkiye's commitment to preserving its cultural heritage, ensuring that Hagia Sophia remains an enduring symbol of historical and architectural significance for future generations.

Great Move: Turkey Revokes the Firman Granting Elgin the Parthenon Marbles

In a dramatic turn of events, Turkey has nullified the firman that allegedly granted Lord Elgin permission to remove the Parthenon Marbles. This document, long cited as Elgin's legal authorization, has been reassessed by Turkish authorities, who now assert that it did not legitimize Elgin's actions. This revocation could significantly impact Greece's efforts to repatriate the Marbles, adding weight to their argument that the artifacts were acquired without proper authorization.

The Parthenon Marbles, also known as the Elgin Marbles, have been a subject of intense debate and controversy since their removal from the Parthenon in Athens in the early 19th century. Lord Elgin, the British ambassador to the Ottoman Empire, orchestrated the removal and transportation of these significant artifacts to Britain. The British Museum has housed the Marbles since their purchase from Elgin, who claimed he had a firman (an official decree) from the Ottoman authorities granting him permission.

However, the legitimacy of this firm has been questioned for many years. Critics argue that Elgin's actions amounted to cultural theft and that the firman, if it existed, did not explicitly permit the dismantling and removal of the sculptures. The Greek government has persistently demanded the return of the Marbles, citing ethical and cultural reasons.

The Turkish Annulment

Recent actions by Turkish authorities have added a new dimension to this longstanding dispute. According to reports, Turkey has officially annulled the firman that Elgin used to justify his removal of the Parthenon Marbles. This decision suggests that the document either never had the legal standing that Elgin claimed or that it has been misinterpreted and misrepresented over the centuries.

Turkish officials, including those in the cultural heritage sector, have highlighted that the firman did not constitute a legal sale or transfer of ownership. Instead, it might have been a mere administrative note, granting limited permission for Elgin to make sketches and perhaps take a few insignificant fragments. This re-evaluation discredits the narrative that Elgin had the right to remove large portions of the Parthenon sculptures.

Implications for Repatriation Efforts

The annulment of the firman significantly strengthens Greece's position in the campaign to repatriate the Parthenon Marbles. Greek authorities have consistently argued that the Marbles were removed illegally and should be returned to their rightful home. The Turkish decision undermines the British Museum's defense that the acquisition was lawful and aboveboard.

This development also highlights the broader issues of cultural heritage and the restitution of artifacts acquired during colonial times. Many countries are re-examining the provenance of their museum collections, and there is growing international support for the return of culturally significant items to their places of origin.

The annulment of the firman by Turkey marks a pivotal moment in the ongoing controversy over the Parthenon Marbles. It challenges the legal foundations of Elgin's actions and bolsters Greece's claims for their return. As the debate continues, this decision may lead to renewed discussions and potential resolutions regarding the rightful home of these invaluable artifacts.

Elgin Plundered the Parthenon Using a Document from a Local Ottoman Official, Lacking Official Authorization

The Controversy of Lord Elgin's Removal of the Parthenon Marbles

In recent historical debates, the legitimacy of Lord Elgin's removal of the Parthenon Marbles has been increasingly scrutinized. New evidence, spearheaded by Turkish archaeologists like Zeynep Boz, has revealed that Elgin's so-called permission to remove the Marbles was not an official decree from the Sultan, as previously claimed, but rather a minor administrative document from a local Ottoman official, or kaymakam. This discovery undermines the longstanding British assertion that Elgin had legitimate authorization for his actions.

Historical Context

During the early 19th century, Thomas Bruce, the 7th Earl of Elgin, was serving as the British ambassador to the Ottoman Empire. Elgin, a lover of Greek art, organized the removal of about half of the Parthenon's remaining sculptures. He justified his actions by claiming he had obtained a firman (an imperial decree) from the Ottoman Sultan granting him permission.

However, historical analysis and the recent findings presented by Boz suggest that Elgin did not possess such a firman. Instead, he had secured a document from a local Ottoman official, which lacked the legal weight and authority of a Sultan's decree. This document allowed him to take sketches and casts of the sculptures but did not explicitly permit the removal of the Marbles themselves.

The supposed firman.

The Legality and Ethics of Elgin's Actions

The revelation that Elgin did not have a firman has significant implications for the legal and ethical debates surrounding the Parthenon Marbles. The British Museum has long defended its possession of the Marbles by asserting that they were legally acquired. However, if Elgin's actions were based on a misrepresentation of his permissions, the argument for their lawful acquisition is substantially weakened.

The ethical considerations are equally compelling. Many people consider the Parthenon Marbles to be a valuable piece of Greek heritage, and their removal would be cultural theft. The Greek government has repeatedly called for their return, asserting that the Marbles belong in their original context, where they can be appreciated as part of the broader narrative of Greek history and identity.

Modern Perspectives and the Call for Repatriation

The debate over the Parthenon Marbles is part of a larger conversation about the repatriation of cultural artifacts. As museums worldwide grapple with the legacies of colonialism and historical injustices, the case of the Parthenon Marbles remains one of the most prominent examples of the complex interplay between cultural heritage, legal frameworks, and ethical responsibilities.

The Greek government continues to advocate for the return of the Marbles, a call that has gained international support. The recent findings about Elgin's lack of proper authorization provide new momentum to these efforts, challenging the British Museum's long-held position and inviting a reevaluation of what constitutes just and fair stewardship of cultural heritage.

The uncovering of the true nature of Elgin's permissions—or lack thereof—reshapes the narrative surrounding one of the most contentious issues in the art world. It underscores the need for transparency and accountability in the stewardship of cultural artifacts and highlights the enduring importance of respecting and preserving the cultural heritage of nations. As the debate continues, it calls into question the legitimacy of retaining artifacts acquired under dubious circumstances and reinforces the ethical imperative to rectify historical wrongs.

Discovery of 18th-Century Glass Bottles at George Washington's Mount Vernon Containing Perfectly Preserved Cherries and Berries

In an exciting archaeological find, 35 glass bottles from the 18th century have been unearthed at George Washington's Mount Vernon during a mansion revitalization project. Most of these bottles contain perfectly preserved cherries and berries, providing a unique glimpse into historical preservation methods and daily life in the era. The discovery not only sheds light on the dietary habits of the time but also offers valuable insights into the culinary practices and food storage techniques used by one of America's founding figures.

Significance of the Discovery

This remarkable find adds a rich layer to our understanding of 18th-century life at Mount Vernon. The preserved fruits inside the bottles suggest that they were likely intended for consumption during the off-season, showcasing early methods of food preservation. This practice would have been essential for ensuring a stable food supply throughout the year, reflecting both the ingenuity and resourcefulness of the period.

Archaeological Insights

The condition of the bottles and their contents provides a rare opportunity for researchers to study the materials and techniques used in glass production and food preservation during the 1700s. The fact that the cherries and berries are perfectly preserved offers clues about the sealing methods and environmental conditions that contributed to their longevity. This discovery could lead to further investigations into the storage practices of the era, providing a more comprehensive picture of daily life at Mount Vernon.

Visitor Experience and Educational Value

For visitors to Mount Vernon, this discovery enhances the historical narrative presented at the site. It brings to life the everyday activities that would have taken place within the mansion, making the history of George Washington and his household more tangible and relatable. The bottles and their contents are expected to be displayed as part of the ongoing efforts to educate the public about the rich history of Mount Vernon.

Conclusion

The unearthing of these 18th-century glass bottles filled with preserved cherries and berries at George Washington's Mount Vernon is a significant archaeological find. It offers a fascinating insight into the food preservation methods of the time and enriches our understanding of daily life in the 18th century. As research continues, these artifacts will undoubtedly provide valuable information for historians and the public alike, further illuminating the legacy of America's first president and his household.

Reopening of an Ancient Beach in Herculaneum Unveils Vivid History

In a remarkable historical revelation, the ancient beach of Herculaneum, buried for centuries by the catastrophic eruption of Mount Vesuvius in 79 CE, has reopened to the public. This rediscovered site provides an evocative glimpse into the past, where the remains of over 330 victims who perished in the eruption have been uncovered, offering a poignant reminder of the tragedy.

Among the poignant discoveries is the skeleton of a man clutching a satchel, highlighting the personal stories amidst the disaster. This site, frozen in time by volcanic ash, offers visitors a unique opportunity to walk the same paths as the ancient Romans and reflect on the human impact of natural disasters.

Archaeological Significance

The reopening of this site is not just a tourist attraction but an important archaeological endeavor. Excavations continue to yield significant finds, enhancing our understanding of the daily lives and final moments of Herculaneum’s inhabitants. The site offers invaluable insights into Roman life, architecture, and the abrupt halt brought by nature’s fury.

Visitor Experience

Visitors to the beach can now explore the preserved ruins and the coastline as it existed nearly two millennia ago. The beach area, now accessible, provides a tangible connection to history, allowing a deeper appreciation of the scale and impact of the Vesuvius eruption. Walking through the site, one can witness the meticulous work of archaeologists and experience the eerie silence of a once-bustling area abruptly abandoned.

Continuing Discoveries

The ongoing excavations continue to reveal new artifacts and human remains, each adding layers to the story of Herculaneum. The skeletons found, including those of children and adults who sought refuge by the sea, underscore the sudden and devastating nature of the eruption. These discoveries not only add to the historical record but also humanize the ancient catastrophe, offering a profound narrative of loss and resilience.

View fullsize

View fullsize

View fullsize

Conclusion

The reopening of Herculaneum’s ancient beach is a significant milestone in archaeological preservation and public history. It invites visitors to engage with the past in a direct and meaningful way, providing a somber reflection on human vulnerability and the enduring legacy of natural disasters. As the site continues to be studied, it promises to yield further secrets and stories from a moment frozen in time, enriching our understanding of ancient civilizations and their untimely ends.

For those interested in exploring this profound piece of history, the newly accessible beach at Herculaneum offers an unparalleled journey into the past, reminding us of the fragility of human life in the face of nature's unpredictable power.

This is the Most Sophisticated Model for Indo-European Language Relationships

---

By Dimosthenis Vasiloudis

---

Modernizing Indo-European Linguistic Mapping: The Complex Model by Raimo Anttila

Introduction: The Evolution of Indo-European Linguistic Studies

The study of Indo-European languages has captivated linguists for centuries, with roots tracing back to the late 18th and early 19th centuries. The discovery of striking similarities between languages such as Sanskrit, Latin, and Greek led to the formulation of the Indo-European hypothesis, positing a common ancestral language. The meticulous work of academics like Sir William Jones, who first proposed the idea of a Proto-Indo-European (PIE) language, and Franz Bopp, who further developed the comparative method to trace the relationships between these languages, marked this early period of comparative linguistics.

Throughout the 19th century, linguists like August Schleicher introduced the tree model to represent the branching nature of language divergence. This model, depicting languages as evolving from a common root through a series of binary splits, became the dominant framework for understanding language relationships. Schleicher's family tree model was groundbreaking, offering a systematic approach to studying linguistic evolution and divergence.

However, as the 20th century progressed, scholars began to recognize the limitations of the tree model. It became apparent that languages do not always diverge in neat, binary splits. Instead, they often exhibit complex patterns of convergence and divergence influenced by various factors such as migration, contact, and socio-political changes. According to Johannes Schmidt's wave model, linguistic features spread across regions like waves in water, resulting in overlapping isoglosses rather than distinct branches.

Schleicher's depiction of the Indo-European language family tree, while groundbreaking for its time, presents a one-dimensional and somewhat misleading picture of linguistic evolution. Languages do not evolve in isolation; rather, they are in constant contact and interaction with neighboring languages. Furthermore, linguistic variations are not as sudden and abrupt as the branching diagram suggests. Instead, they result from long and gradual processes of divergence from a common ancestor, aligning with the core principles of historical comparative linguistics. This gradual divergence reflects the complex and interconnected nature of language development, which the traditional tree model fails to fully capture.

In recent decades, advances in computational methods and phylogenetic analysis have revolutionized the field. Linguists now employ sophisticated tools to analyze large datasets of linguistic features, revealing more nuanced patterns of language change and interaction. These modern approaches have led to the development of network models, such as those proposed by Raimo Anttila, which capture the intricate web of relationships between languages more accurately than the traditional tree model.

Today, the study of Indo-European languages continues to evolve, integrating insights from historical linguistics, archaeology, and genetics. Scholars strive to unravel the complex history of language divergence, seeking to understand not only how languages are related but also the historical contexts that shaped their development. The journey from the early tree models to contemporary network analyses reflects the dynamic and interdisciplinary nature of linguistic research, highlighting the ongoing quest to map the rich tapestry of human language.

Introduction to Anttila's Model

---

Understanding Linguistic Change Through Lexical Polymorphism: A New Parametric Model

---

Raimo Anttila's modernized model of Indo-European dialect mapping represents a significant advancement over the traditional tree model. Using 24 isolinguals from various branches of the Indo-European language family, Anttila's model provides a nuanced and intricate depiction of language relationships. This complexity, while challenging to interpret, offers a more faithful reflection of the historical and geographical landscape of Indo-European languages. In this model, the original centum and satem distinctions proposed by Antoine Meillet are preserved but modernized, incorporating the languages Hittite and Tocharian into the centum category.

Preserving and Modernizing Centum and Satem Distinctions

Anttila's model retains Meillet's centum and satem distinctions, which categorize Indo-European languages based on their treatment of certain Proto-Indo-European consonants. Centum languages, including Hittite and Tocharian, maintain the original velar stops, while satem languages show a shift to sibilants. By integrating Hittite and Tocharian, Anttila not only modernizes but also reinforces these distinctions. Hittite's inclusion is particularly notable due to its central geographical position within the Indo-European world, reflecting the Indo-Hittite hypothesis, which suggests Hittite's pivotal role in early Indo-European history.

Centrality of Hittite and Tocharian

The centrality of Hittite in Anttila's model is a crucial element. Hittite occupies the exact geographical center of the Indo-European language family, a position that underscores its historical and linguistic significance. This central placement echoes Anttila's support for the Indo-Hittite hypothesis, proposing that Hittite and its related Anatolian languages form a distinct, early branch of Indo-European. Similarly, Tocharian, despite being geographically eastern, is grouped with the centum languages due to its conservative linguistic features. Both Hittite and Tocharian exhibit fewer common innovations with other Indo-European languages, highlighting their conservative nature and reinforcing their central roles in the family.

---

New Analysis Suggests An Emergence Of Indo-European Languages Around 8000 Years Ago

---

Reflecting the True Complexity of Indo-European Linguistic Landscape

Anttila's model, with its intricate web of relationships, better captures the complexity of Indo-European linguistic history compared to the simplistic binary splits of traditional tree models. The web-like structure of Anttila's map reflects a more realistic scenario where languages influence each other through continuous contact and migration, resulting in overlapping isoglosses. This network approach provides a more accurate depiction of how languages evolve, interact, and diverge, acknowledging the multifaceted nature of linguistic development. By illustrating the interconnections and shared features among languages, Anttila's model aligns more closely with historical linguistic evidence, offering a comprehensive understanding of the Indo-European language family's evolution.

---

New Study Traces Linguistic Paths: How Language Dispersal Echoes Ancient DNA And Archaeological Findings

---

Conclusion

Raimo Anttila's modernized model of Indo-European dialect mapping represents a sophisticated and detailed approach to understanding language relationships. By preserving and updating Meillet's centum and satem distinctions and emphasizing the centrality of Hittite and Tocharian, Anttila's model offers a more nuanced and accurate reflection of the Indo-European linguistic landscape. This complex, web-like structure captures the true nature of language evolution and interaction, making it a valuable tool for historical linguistics. Anttila's model stands as a testament to the intricate and dynamic history of the Indo-European language family, highlighting the importance of considering both historical and geographical contexts in linguistic studies.

Andrew Higgins Explores North Macedonia's Identity Crisis in The New York Times

Who Owns Alexander the Great? A Diplomatic Minefield

On June 19, 2024, Andrew Higgins of The New York Times published an insightful article titled "Who Owns Alexander the Great? It’s a Diplomatic Minefield." The article delves into North Macedonia's efforts to forge a national identity by claiming historical figures, a move that has stirred diplomatic tensions with neighboring countries.

Historical Claims and Regional Reactions

North Macedonia, a relatively young Balkan nation, has sought to bolster its national identity by erecting statues of historical figures like Alexander the Great and his father, Philip II of Macedon, in its capital, Skopje. These efforts, part of the larger "Skopje 2014" project, have sparked controversy. The statues symbolize a rich history, but this history is also claimed by Greece and Bulgaria, leading to significant diplomatic disputes.

“Searching for a historical anchor with which to secure a new country whose only previous experience as an independent state lasted just 10 days in 1903, the central government a decade ago poured hundreds of millions of euros into a vast redevelopment project for Skopje. It filled the city center with statues and turned drab government and commercial buildings into colonnaded palaces resembling a kitschy Hollywood set for a movie about ancient times.”, he says.

---

Macedonia: Greek Or Slavic?

---

Greece and the Name Dispute

Greece has long contested North Macedonia's use of historical Macedonian figures, arguing that they are an integral part of Greek heritage. The disagreement culminated in the Prespa Agreement of 2018, wherein North Macedonia agreed to change its name to the Republic of North Macedonia. This agreement was intended to ease tensions and facilitate North Macedonia’s entry into NATO and the European Union. However, the statues of Alexander the Great and other historical symbols continue to be points of contention.

---

What Did Orator Demosthenes Say About Ancient Macedonians?

---

Bulgaria's Historical Contentions

Bulgaria has also expressed strong objections, particularly over historical figures it considers Bulgarian. This adds another layer of complexity to North Macedonia’s EU aspirations. The issue of identity and historical claims remains deeply contentious, affecting regional relationships and North Macedonia's political landscape.

Internal Views and Criticism

Within North Macedonia, opinions are divided. Slavica Babamova, director of the national archaeological museum, argues that the country has a rich history of its own that should be celebrated without the need for what she sees as excessive historical marketing. She points out that some of the most significant artifacts from the region predate Alexander the Great and have genuine connections to North Macedonian heritage.

---

The Pella Curse Tablet: A Linguistic Window Into Ancient Macedonia

---

Conclusion by Andrew Higgins

Andrew Higgins concludes that the quest for a national identity in North Macedonia is fraught with challenges and diplomatic pitfalls. The overlapping histories and identities in the Balkans create a complex tapestry where claims and counterclaims often lead to conflict. The region's history is fluid and intertwined, making the task of establishing a distinct national narrative particularly challenging.

This article by Andrew Higgins for The New York Times underscores the ongoing struggle of nations to define their identity and the often contentious nature of historical claims in the Balkan region.

Back to the Beginning: The Best Movies Set in Prehistoric Times

---

1. One Million Years B.C. (1966)

2. Quest for Fire (1981)

3. The Clan of the Cave Bear (1986)

4. 10,000 BC (2008)

5. Alpha (2018)

6. Walking with Dinosaurs (2013)

7. The Land Before Time (1988)

8. When Dinosaurs Ruled the Earth (1970)

9. Caveman (1981)

10. Prehistoric Women (1967)

---

Travel back to a time when mammoths roamed the earth and our ancestors first began to shape the world. The prehistoric period has always been a source of fascination for filmmakers and audiences alike. Over the years, we've seen countless movies set in this era, from campy B-movies to big-budget blockbusters. In this article, we'll take a look at the best movies set in prehistoric times, exploring their unique stories, themes, and cinematic achievements.

1. One Million Years B.C. (1966)

Directed by Don Chaffey, "One Million Years B.C." is a classic film best known for its stunning visual effects and Ray Harryhausen's incredible stop-motion animation. Set in the prehistoric era, this film tells the story of Tumak, a caveman who is banished from his tribe and forced to survive in the harsh and unforgiving world of the Stone Age. Along the way, he encounters various prehistoric creatures and eventually falls in love with Loana, a woman from a more advanced tribe.

This film is iconic for its portrayal of the prehistoric world, featuring groundbreaking special effects and memorable creatures such as the giant turtle, the brontosaurus, and the allosaurus. The movie is also famous for featuring a then-unknown Raquel Welch in a fur bikini, which has since become an iconic image in pop culture.

2. Quest for Fire (1981)

"Quest for Fire," directed by Jean-Jacques Annaud, is a critically acclaimed film that delves into the lives and struggles of a small tribe of prehistoric humans. Set 80,000 years ago, the film follows the tribe's journey to find a new source of fire after their precious flame is accidentally extinguished. Along the way, they encounter various tribes and creatures and ultimately discover the secret of creating fire.

Based on the novel by J.H. Rosny Sr., the film is known for its dedication to historical accuracy and its creative use of language. Linguistic expert Anthony Burgess developed a unique prehistoric language for the characters to speak, giving the film an authentic feel. The film also features detailed and realistic costume and set designs, further immersing the viewer in the prehistoric world.

3. The Clan of the Cave Bear (1986)

Based on the best-selling novel by Jean M. Auel, "The Clan of the Cave Bear" tells the story of Ayla, a young girl who is orphaned and raised by a tribe of Neanderthals. Directed by Michael Chapman, the film explores themes of survival, adaptation, and the clash of cultures as Ayla struggles to find her place in a world that doesn't understand her.

Daryl Hannah's performance as Ayla is highly praised, as is the film's realistic portrayal of prehistoric life. The movie is also notable for its beautiful cinematography, capturing the breathtaking landscapes of the prehistoric world.

4. 10,000 BC (2008)

"10,000 BC" is a big-budget epic directed by Roland Emmerich that takes viewers on a thrilling adventure through the prehistoric world. The film follows D'Leh, a young hunter who embarks on a perilous journey to rescue his love, Evolet, after she is kidnapped by an advanced civilization. Along the way, D'Leh encounters various prehistoric creatures and forms alliances with other tribes, leading to an epic battle for the future of humanity.

Despite mixed reviews, "10,000 BC" is known for its stunning visual effects, bringing the prehistoric world to life in a way never seen before. The film is also notable for its exploration of early human societies and the impact of cultural and technological advancements on their way of life.

5. Alpha (2018)

"Alpha," directed by Albert Hughes, is a visually stunning film that tells the story of a young hunter named Keda, who is left for dead after a hunting expedition goes awry. Set in the last Ice Age, the film follows Keda's journey to reunite with his tribe, accompanied by a lone wolf that he befriends along the way. Their bond grows stronger as they rely on each other for survival in the harsh and unforgiving wilderness.

"Alpha" is praised for its breathtaking cinematography and the unique bond portrayed between Keda and his wolf companion, symbolizing the early domestication of dogs by humans. The film is also known for its accurate portrayal of prehistoric environments and its focus on the human-animal relationship in our evolutionary history.

6. Walking with Dinosaurs (2013)

Based on the groundbreaking BBC documentary series of the same name, "Walking with Dinosaurs" is a family-friendly film that brings the prehistoric world to life through cutting-edge CGI technology. Directed by Barry Cook and Neil Nightingale, the film follows the adventures of Patchi, a young Pachyrhinosaurus, as he navigates the challenges of growing up in a world filled with danger and wonder.

"Walking with Dinosaurs" is celebrated for its educational value, providing audiences with a glimpse into the lives of dinosaurs and the environments they inhabited. The film's stunning visual effects and attention to detail make it a must-watch for anyone interested in prehistoric life.

7. The Land Before Time (1988)

"The Land Before Time" is an animated classic directed by Don Bluth, which has captivated the hearts of children and adults alike since its release. The film follows the journey of Littlefoot, a young Apatosaurus, who becomes separated from his family during an earthquake. Along the way, he befriends other young dinosaurs, including Cera the Triceratops, Ducky the Saurolophus, Petrie the Pteranodon, and Spike the Stegosaurus. Together, they embark on a quest to find the legendary Great Valley, a place of safety and abundance.

With its endearing characters and heartwarming story, "The Land Before Time" remains a beloved classic that has spawned numerous sequels and spin-offs, introducing new generations to the wonders of the prehistoric world.

8. When Dinosaurs Ruled the Earth (1970)

Directed by Val Guest, "When Dinosaurs Ruled the Earth" is a British film that takes place in a prehistoric world inhabited by both humans and dinosaurs. The film follows a tribe of cavemen as they struggle for survival and attempt to navigate the dangers posed by the massive creatures that share their world.

Featuring impressive stop-motion animation by Jim Danforth, the film was nominated for an Academy Award for Best Visual Effects. "When Dinosaurs Ruled the Earth" is best remembered for its creative depiction of the prehistoric world and the awe-inspiring dinosaurs that ruled it.

9. Caveman (1981)

This comedy film, directed by Carl Gottlieb, stars Ringo Starr as Atouk, a bumbling caveman who is banished from his tribe due to his infatuation with the chief's mate. Atouk then forms his own tribe of misfits, as they face various challenges and comedic misadventures in their quest for survival.

"Caveman" is known for its slapstick humor and lighthearted take on prehistoric life, offering a fun and entertaining look at the trials and tribulations of our ancestors.

10. Prehistoric Women (1967)

"Prehistoric Women," also known as "Slave Girls," is a campy British film directed by Michael Carreras. Set in a prehistoric world, the film tells the story of a tribe of Amazonian women who enslave men and use them as laborers and breeding stock. However, when a male hunter named David stumbles upon their hidden society, he sets in motion a chain of events that leads to a revolt against the oppressive female regime.

While not critically acclaimed, "Prehistoric Women" is a cult classic that offers a unique, tongue-in-cheek take on prehistoric society and gender dynamics.

Conclusion

From thrilling adventures to touching stories of survival, these movies set in prehistoric times showcase the incredible power of cinema to transport us to a world long gone. Each film offers a unique perspective on the lives of our ancestors and the creatures that once roamed the earth, providing an engaging and immersive experience for audiences of all ages. As technology and our understanding of the prehistoric world continue to advance, we can expect even more captivating stories to be told on the big screen, further deepening our connection to the past.